Detranstioners speak out against California's transgender refuge state bill
( Post Millennial )
On Wednesday, California State Senator Scott Wiener announced that the "transgender state of refuge bill" has passed through its final Assembly committee, and now heads to the Assembly floor for a vote.
"Our transgender state of refuge bill (SB 107) — ensuring families with trans kids can seek refuge in CA if other states criminalize them for allowing their kids to get healthcare — just passed its final Assembly committee & heads to the Assembly floor. Thank you, colleagues," Wiener wrote.
SB 107 would make the state a safe haven for child gender procedures, prohibiting out-of-state law forces from acting on subpoenas, warrants, and child custody issues if the child was brought into the state for procedures like surgical gender reassignments or the prescribing of cross-sex hormones.
The bill, introduced in 2021 by Wiener, would prohibit any providers of health care, including insurance agencies and contractors, from releasing "medical information related to sensitive services or related to a person or entity allowing a child to receive gender-affirming health care" if this information is being "requested pursuant to another state’s law that authorizes a person to bring a civil action against a person or entity who allows a child to receive gender-affirming health care."
The bill would also "prohibit law enforcement agencies from making, or intentionally participating in, the arrest of an individual pursuant to an out-of-state arrest warrant based on another state’s law against receiving or allowing a child to receive gender-affirming health care."
In regards to child custody issues, "The bill would prohibit the enforcement of an order based on another state’s law authorizing a child to be removed from their parent or guardian based on that parent or guardian allowing their child to receive gender-affirming health care."
The bill would also allow a court of the state to have temporary emergency jurisdiction over a child if they have been abandoned in the state, or if they have fled to the state because a family disallowed receiving gender-affirming care.
Chloe Cole, who has previously spoken out against the bill, wrote in a response to Wiener’s tweet, "As a de-transitioner that has testified across from Scott Weiner on this bill, I can say that this bill has many unintended consequences, many intended consequences that are immoral, and will take away rights from parents across the entire US."
Cole had previously recited her experiences with transitioning and de-transitioning in front of the California state assembly, saying "Despite having therapists and attending the top surgery class, I really didn't understand all the ramifications of any of the medical decisions I was making."
"I will never be able to breastfeed a child. I have blood clots in my urine. I am unable to fully empty my bladder. I do not yet know if I'm capable of carrying a child to full term. In fact, even the doctors who put me on puberty blockers and testosterone do not know. SB 107 is circumventing state's laws, And have needed safeguards in place so my story is not repeated. Children cannot consent."
Other Twitter users criticized Wiener’s post, saying children have not developed enough intellectually to consider the long-term risks associated with the treatments.
Think wacky California laws don't affect you because you live outside of California? This law would allow your minor children to come to California and begin irreversible medical gender transition without your permission. https://t.co/msowDab0tA — Abigail Shrier (@AbigailShrier) August 8, 2022
The brain continues to develop during adolescence, esp. the prefrontal cortex which is critical for decision making/executive functions & has an especially late developmental trajectory. So much so that it used in criminal cases and sentencing. How then does it not matter here ? — monika chancey (@ChanceyMonika) August 8, 2022
“Criminalize them for getting healthcare”; are you referring to removal of breasts on girls or penises on boys? That’s not healthcare it is child abuse. — I love Churchill (@mkzchurchill) August 10, 2022